This course is intended to prepare you to deal with ethical
situations that you are likely to encounter as a computer professional. One
aspect was to make you aware of the kinds of ethical issues that are associated
with IT. Another aspect was to make you aware of the issues that the
professional associations have focused upon in building a code of ethics for
computer professionals. A third aspect was to demonstrate areas and arguments
that have been presented by ethicists as matters of concern. A forth aspect has
been to develop a basis for analyzing situations and discerning whether an
ethical issue is present and who it affects. A fifth aspect has been
illustrating how to rationalize and justify a course of action based upon
principles that have been developed by philosophers and ethicists in our
society.
The authors we have read make
that case that computer ethics--concerns about the applications of IT--present
new problems regarding fairness and benefit to humankind that are different
from those posed by previous technologies. As a consequence, computer
professionals need to exercise great care lest their creations spawn a host of
unintended consequences. From the beginning the argument has been that there
are policy gaps regarding what behaviors in Cyberspace are ethical because such
behaviors were never possible previously.
On the final you will be asked
to analyze one or more scenarios and to write about some of the following:
- What are the 8 principles of
behavior that the SE code of ethics requires of computer professionals and
what are the ethical, philosophical, or religious bases for them (what
validity do they have)?
- What does the SE code have to
say about
- privacy in cyberspace?
- activities on the
Internet?
- intellectual property?
- democracy?
- What is the relationship of a
society's laws to professional ethics (what in the code of ethics
justifies a computer professional in America to break any of the few US
laws that pertain to IT)?
- What in the SE code of ethics
mandates that the computer professional advocate or denounce any
particular computer application that may be proposed by some commercial or
governmental entity?
- Identify a policy gap in
Cyberspace (some area of application that "good people" might
differ as to whether more harm or good was attached to a particular
application in that area)and explain how a governing policy should be
established.
- Suppose you are assigned to
design a new IT application. What questions would you ask to determine if
this application was entirely ethical (be thorough)?
- How does automating an
activity considered benign when conducted manually raise ethical concerns
(give examples)?
- Discuss some practices that
may be part of the IT workplace (within companies that provide computer
products and services) that are ethically questionable.
- IT applications exist in all
companies and most companies have IT workers who support those
applications. Are such workers in non-IT companies computer professionals
and do any of the 8 principles of the SE code apply to them (justify your
conclusions)?
- Assume two employees in a
large bank, one with an accounting degree and one with an information
science degree. Both support the bank's website, one by developing
products and services offered electronically to customers, the other by
insuring that the webpages, the webserver, and the database function properly.
Are one, both, or neither employees bound by any or all of the 8
principles of the SE code of ethics (explain)?
- List some ways in which the intellectual
circumstances and environment of the IT workplace for IT professionals
differ from the workplace of other knowledge workers (stock brokers,
librarians, teachers, industrial managers, military strategists, lawyers,
etc.). Relate these differences to the unique responsibilities that IT
professionals bear.
The
Final exam will be in two parts: You may turn in before receiving the exam a
one page, handwritten, open book response for each of any two of the bulleted
questions from above. You will then be asked to write closed-book on two
questions that I choose. The four one-page essays will count 80% of the final.
The 32 essays will be graded by assigning each to one of eleven piles and then
ranking each pile, assigning a score <=20 to the highest ranked response,
and deducting from that score appropriately for the lesser quality of the lower
ranked responses.